We have been ordering pizza from here for months now, at least twice a month. The pizza is by far the best up the Keys, the crust is always crispy and never soggy, the price is fair for the Keys (this ain't Dominos) JS.
I love this pizza and the service is great(super friendly staff), awesome prices for great pizza would 100% recommend!
I suggest picking up bc as with most pizza deliveries, by the time you get it, the crust gets soggy.
Ask for garlic, you get it! I think overall the crust makes this pizza and we like it tremendously, so much so, hubby is driving 7 miles to pick it up LOL!
Anyway, we always order the vegetarian, only critique, needs a tiny bit more red pepper:-), but you can ask for extra.
We live close by and we order the pizza and salads frequently. The pizza reminds me if a traditional brick oven NY style pizza, I have yet to be disappointed. Their house salad has a big portabella mushroom with it and is delicious with their homeade house dressing.
Stopped here expecting a so-so lunch, but got the mahi-mahi and fried shrimp sandwich and they were fantastic. But the bar tender was an older grumpy fella who didn't know how to make the couple of drinks we asked for, not a problem. But he got embarrassed and made fun of us for wanting something other than Malibu rum, a little weird.
The food is pretty good,, I wish they open earlier then 7:00am like at least 6:00am..
Sugarloaf Pizza is a US Meal Delivery based in Sugarloaf Key, Florida. Sugarloaf Pizza is located at 17075 Overseas Hwy, Sugarloaf Key, FL 33042, USA.
Please contact with Sugarloaf Pizza using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Sugarloaf Pizza opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.